State deploys new tactic in bid to get suit over Peter Boy Kema’s death tossed

State employs new tactic to avoid lawsuit over its role in Peter Boy's death

HONOLULU, Hawaii (HawaiiNewsNow) - The state appears to be relying on a technicality in a bid to avoid a civil lawsuit over the death of Peter Kema, Jr., known as Peter Boy.

The Kema siblings are suing the state in a wrongful death case.

But the state is arguing the family took too long to file the lawsuit ― 20 years too long.

That’s even though the siblings didn’t know for sure that Peter Boy was dead until their mother’s courtroom confession on Dec. 1, 2016.

In their lawsuit, the family accuses the state of failing to act on reports and outcries that the children ― and especially the 6-year old ― were being abused before his murder in 1997.

Peter Boy Kema and his siblings in 1996. Picture courtesy the family
Peter Boy Kema and his siblings in 1996. Picture courtesy the family

Their mother, Jaylin Kema, admitted in court that she did not get Peter Boy medical treatment after his father caused a wound that got infected. It was so bad, it smelled horrible and his flesh rotted.

The boy died from the infection after months of suffering.

Peter Kema, Sr., is serving a 20-year sentence for manslaughter while Jaylin Kema died in January from a medical condition.

Peter Kema Sr. appears in court after his arrest in the 1997 murder of his son. (Image: Pool Photo)
Peter Kema Sr. appears in court after his arrest in the 1997 murder of his son. (Image: Pool Photo)

The attorney for the siblings, Randall Rosenberg, says the state Department of Human Services also bears responsibility for the boy’s death.

It was well-documented that the Kemas abused the children, but state Child Protective Services, a branch of DHS, returned the children to them.

In January 1997, their grandparents reported that they saw Peter Boy with a black eye and a wound on his arm. The state took no action, according to Rosenberg and the grandfather, James Acol.

Grandparents James and Yolanda Acol during the search for their grandson
Grandparents James and Yolanda Acol during the search for their grandson

Then, in April 1997, a counselor reported that Peter Boy had a broken arm that caused by his father and that the father made Peter Boy eat dog feces as punishment.

“Those facts are clear and inescapable," Rosenberg said, "The state made mistakes at the time, the most critical time in Peter Boy’s life, and they didn’t act. As a result, he was murdered.”

Rosenberg said three months after the counselor’s report, in July 1997, an investigator was finally sent to the Kema home, but it was too late. Peter Boy was not there.

The parents reported him missing, saying they dropped him off on Oahu with an “Aunty Rose Makuakane,” a lie that threw off the search efforts to find Peter Boy.

Related coverage:

The siblings filed the civil suit shortly after their mother’s admission in court, but the state is now saying the statute of limitations ― two years after death ― had run out.

“This is a technicality and it’s the worst kind of technicality, because they know that the children, the siblings of Peter Boy, could not have filed earlier," Rosenberg said.

He added the state is taking advantage of the 20-year gap when the boy was missing.

Randall Rosenberg, Attorney for the siblings of Peter Boy Kema
Randall Rosenberg, Attorney for the siblings of Peter Boy Kema

After Peter Boy was reported missing, the siblings were taken from the Kemas and grew up with relatives, the grandparents.

They thrived despite the years of abuse and witnessing their brother’s horrifying last few months.

“These are wonderful kids and all three of them have become parents, all three, and they’re the best parents I have ever seen. They have somehow managed to survive this,” Rosenberg said, choking back tears.

Hawaii News Now did reach out to the State Department of Human Services.

In a written statement, a spokesperson said the agency could not comment on active litigation. “However,” the spokesperson said, "we recognize the difficulty that the family has been through.”

Copyright 2019 Hawaii News Now. All rights reserved.