Examining Online Video Sharing and Legal Responsibility - Hawaii News Now - KGMB and KHNL

Examining Online Video Sharing and Legal Responsibility

Rick Fried Rick Fried

By Leland Kim

DOWNTOWN HONOLULU (KHNL) --  A YouTube video of what appears to be a U.S. Marine throwing a puppy into a ravine continues to cause outrage. Wednesday, the people for the ethical treatment of animals, or PETA, calls for the court-martial of the Marines involved.

And that's not the only shocking video that's popping up on YouTube.  The latest controversy involves the videotaping of an alleged gang rape in front of the victim's young children. That video was then uploaded onto YouTube.

It was taken down when people complained, but what are the legal responsibilities of video sharing sites like YouTube?

Controversy surrounding the most popular video sharing Web site.  Just in the past few days, the spotlight has been on YouTube, after members posted video clips of U.S. service members engaging in alleged animal abuse.

Wednesday, more heat on YouTube, after an alleged gang rape was uploaded onto its Web site.  These videos violate YouTube's user agreement and have been taken down.

"YouTube's lawyers have been very careful," said prominent Honolulu attorney Rick Fried, a founding member of Cronin, Fried, Sekiya, Kekina & Fairbanks, the largest personal injury law firm in Honolulu. "They say in their material that this is not a shock site.  We're not supposed to post things that are gross like this rape incident."

Fried said YouTube and parent company Google probably are protected legally since they took down the videos after they were flagged.

"An example that comes to mind: let's assume you take a picture of your neighbor's wife and put a copy of it on a Hawaiian (Telcom) telephone pole. Is Hawaiian (Telcom) responsible?" asked Fried. "Probably not, unless they see it and don't do anything about it."

That's why YouTube says it has a zero tolerance policy on violators.  In a written statement, a YouTube spokesperson said, "If the content breaks our terms then we remove it and if a user repeatedly breaks the rules we disable their account. If the police ask us for information, we will cooperate, so long as they follow the correct legal process that the government introduced."

YouTube users upload about ten hours of video every minute, which makes it almost impossible to monitor content.

"One of the advantages of something like YouTube is the instantaneous nature of it," said Fried.  "And so for them to be obligated to check every single posting before it goes on, is kind of a murky and difficult situation."

So unless YouTube did not take down the offending video after they were notified, people like the alleged rape victim probably don't have a case against YouTube.

"Unless they were to ignore their own warning which is check if inappropriate, I think at this point, it would be difficult to prevail in litigation against them," said Fried.

An intersection of the Internet, crime, and responsibility in cyberspace.

A YouTube spokesperson points out that the site is used by millions of people in positive ways.  She added, there is only a tiny fraction of people who try to break the rules.

Job Link 8 Featured Jobs
  • Hawaii News Now headlinesNewsMore>>

  • Forecast: Mostly clear skies, some vog ahead of strong cold front

    Forecast: Mostly clear skies, some vog ahead of strong cold front

    Monday, December 18 2017 12:04 AM EST2017-12-18 05:04:59 GMT
    Image: Hawaii News NowImage: Hawaii News Now

    Light winds and mostly clear skies are in the forecast for Monday, but an approaching cold front will combine with abundant moisture from the south to bring heavy showers and a chance of thunderstorms to most of the state by Monday night and Tuesday.

    More >>

    Light winds and mostly clear skies are in the forecast for Monday, but an approaching cold front will combine with abundant moisture from the south to bring heavy showers and a chance of thunderstorms to most of the state by Monday night and Tuesday.

    More >>
  • Flash Flood Watch to take effect Monday night

    Flash Flood Watch to take effect Monday night

    Sunday, December 17 2017 10:58 PM EST2017-12-18 03:58:55 GMT
    Image: Kevin Olson/FileImage: Kevin Olson/File

    Abundant moisture ahead of a slow-moving cold front could result in heavy showers and thunderstorms starting Monday night for Oahu, Maui County and the Big Island. 

    More >>

    Abundant moisture ahead of a slow-moving cold front could result in heavy showers and thunderstorms starting Monday night for Oahu, Maui County and the Big Island. 

    More >>
  • 'Sand mattress' central to new effort to save Waikiki beach

    'Sand mattress' central to new effort to save Waikiki beach

    Sunday, December 17 2017 10:19 PM EST2017-12-18 03:19:10 GMT
    (Image: City & County of Honolulu)(Image: City & County of Honolulu)

    On Sunday, Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell joined other environmental experts to announce a new effort aimed at addressing chronic erosion at Hawaii's most famous beach.

    More >>

    On Sunday, Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell joined other environmental experts to announce a new effort aimed at addressing chronic erosion at Hawaii's most famous beach.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly