Judge: Montana murder case not a 'crime of violence' - Hawaii News Now - KGMB and KHNL

Judge: Montana murder case not a 'crime of violence'

By MATTHEW BROWN
Associated Press

BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) - A Montana man faces resentencing next month in the 2003 murder of his uncle after a judge said the shooting did not meet the definition of a violent crime.

Quinton Birdinground Jr., 38, is scheduled to appear Aug. 23 before U.S. District Judge Susan Watters in Billings.

Federal Defender David Ness said Wednesday he expects to ask for a sentence of time served - meaning Birdinground would be released - but has not made a final decision.

Birdinground is serving 24 years in federal prison for assaulting his estranged girlfriend and killing Emerson Pickett during an argument in Crow Agency after a night of drinking.

The original sentence included 10 years for using a firearm during a violent crime.

Watters this month threw out that conviction, saying the violent crime law was so vague as to be unconstitutional. She cited a 2015 Supreme Court ruling.

Birdinground will be resentenced on two remaining counts: second-degree murder and assault resulting in serious bodily injury.

Birdinground has been incarcerated for more than 15 years since his arrest in February 2003.

If he were released, Ness said Birdinground likely would remain under supervision of federal authorities for some period of time.

He was charged with killing Pickett after finding the victim with Birdinground's estranged girlfriend, Leitha Yellowmule. Yellowmule's hand was grazed by the same bullet that killed Pickett, prosecutors said.

The defense had argued at Birdinground's trial that the shooting was accidental.

In her order throwing out the charge of using a firearm during a violent crime, Watters wrote that neither second-degree murder nor assault is itself considered a "crime of violence" under federal law. That's because they may have been committed recklessly rather than intentionally, as is required to be considered a violent crime.

"Birdinground used a firearm, but not 'during and in relation to a crime of violence,' " Watters wrote.

U.S. Attorney Kurt Alme declined to say whether prosecutors will request a new sentence that would keep Birdinground in prison.

Alme's office is reviewing the case with the Office of Solicitor General at the Justice Department for a possible appeal of Watters' decision, but that can't be filed until after sentencing, he said.

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • NationalMore>>

  • Tears, then giggles: Honduran baby is back in parents' arms

    Tears, then giggles: Honduran baby is back in parents' arms

    Friday, July 20 2018 2:50 PM EDT2018-07-20 18:50:19 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 8:22 PM EDT2018-07-21 00:22:17 GMT
    (AP Photo/Esteban Felix). In this July 18, 2018 photo, Rolando Bueso Castillo and his wife Adalicia Montecinos, stand in their home in La Libertad, Honduras. It's been five months since they have seen their infant son Johan Bueso Castillo who was separ...(AP Photo/Esteban Felix). In this July 18, 2018 photo, Rolando Bueso Castillo and his wife Adalicia Montecinos, stand in their home in La Libertad, Honduras. It's been five months since they have seen their infant son Johan Bueso Castillo who was separ...
    A Honduran man who was separated from his baby son at the Texas border and then deported without him soon will hold the boy again.More >>
    A Honduran man who was separated from his baby son at the Texas border and then deported without him soon will hold the boy again.More >>
  • Colorado VA hospital plagued by delays, high costs to open

    Colorado VA hospital plagued by delays, high costs to open

    Friday, July 20 2018 3:05 PM EDT2018-07-20 19:05:09 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 8:21 PM EDT2018-07-21 00:21:34 GMT
    (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File). FILE - In this June 8, 2017, file photo, the campus of the Veterans Administration hospital is under construction in Aurora, Colo. The center is set to open Saturday, July 21, 2018, years behind schedule and more than...(AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File). FILE - In this June 8, 2017, file photo, the campus of the Veterans Administration hospital is under construction in Aurora, Colo. The center is set to open Saturday, July 21, 2018, years behind schedule and more than...
    It's more than $1 billion over budget and five years behind schedule, but an elaborate new veterans hospital is finally opening in suburban Denver with the promise of state-of-the-art medical care.More >>
    It's more than $1 billion over budget and five years behind schedule, but an elaborate new veterans hospital is finally opening in suburban Denver with the promise of state-of-the-art medical care.More >>
  • Ohio killer spared after extent of childhood abuse revealed

    Ohio killer spared after extent of childhood abuse revealed

    Friday, July 20 2018 11:17 AM EDT2018-07-20 15:17:17 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 8:19 PM EDT2018-07-21 00:19:11 GMT
    Ohio Gov. John Kasich has spared a condemned killer whose sentence was challenged after a juror came forward with concerns that the extent of the inmate's childhood abuse was shielded at trial.More >>
    Ohio Gov. John Kasich has spared a condemned killer whose sentence was challenged after a juror came forward with concerns that the extent of the inmate's childhood abuse was shielded at trial.More >>
Powered by Frankly