Aussie tourist pleads no contest to negligent homicide - Hawaii News Now - KGMB and KHNL

Aussie tourist pleads no contest to negligent homicide

Tyson Dagley in court Thursday morning Tyson Dagley in court Thursday morning
Kristen Fonseca Kristen Fonseca
HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) -

HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - Tyson Dagley pleaded no contest Thursday to the charge of negligent homicide in the third degree.

His attorney, Walter Rodby, said the decision to waive a jury trial was made after he and Dagley saw written accounts and video of the jet ski collision in Keehi Lagoon that killed 16-year-old Kristen Fonseca of Vacaville, CA.

"Our review of the police reports and the videos indicates that at the time of the impact he wasn't looking straight ahead," Rodby said.

Fonseca died of a brain injury. The police report said she had slowed down her watercraft just before impact. Dagley, 20, was going full speed and looking at his girlfriend, who was taking pictures of him.

"Are you pleading no contest of your own free will?" Circuit Court Judge Richard Perkins asked him.

"Yes, sir," Dagley answered.

Fonseca's stepfather, Mario Canton, told Hawaii News Now he's relieved.

"I have mixed feelings," he said. "I'm pleased that he pled. At the same time I wanted it to all get out there to show the full ramifications of his actions and his negligence."

Rodby asked for a deferred acceptance of the plea. If it's granted the conviction would be wiped off Dagley's U.S.record if he stays out of trouble for a year.

"That charge is a misdemeanor and it carries a maximum penalty of one year in jail and a $2,000 fine," Perkins reminded Dagley.

Canton said his family wants Dagley to receive the maximum punishment law allows despite emotional pleas they've seen Dagley make in news accounts.

"We don't feel that he's remorseful," Canton said. "We have yet to hear from him or his family."

"You could see the toll today. You can see it on their faces. It's been extremely difficult," Rodby said.

Dagley was ordered to surrender his Australian passport to the court. He assured the judge he will stay in Hawaii until he's sentenced September 5th.

Stay with HawaiiNewsNow.com for the latest updates.

Copyright 2012 Hawaii News Now. All rights reserved.

Top Stories

Dagley homicide case (SIDEBAR)

Updated:

Man arrested in fatal jet ski crash Calif. teen's family sues tourist, Aloha Jet Ski Bail stays at $100,000 in Hawaii Jet Ski crash Police arrest girlfriend of tourist booked in jet ski death More>>

  • Hawaii News Now headlinesNewsMore>>

  • Uber driver in US illegally charged with 4 California rapes

    Uber driver in US illegally charged with 4 California rapes

    Monday, January 22 2018 4:27 PM EST2018-01-22 21:27:48 GMT
    Wednesday, January 24 2018 4:59 AM EST2018-01-24 09:59:32 GMT
    California prosecutors say a Mexican Uber driver living in the country illegally has been charged with raping, assaulting and robbing young women.More >>
    California prosecutors say a Mexican Uber driver living in the country illegally has been charged with raping, assaulting and robbing young women.More >>
  • 'Peter Boy Kema Act' seeks to close loophole in criminal justice system

    'Peter Boy Kema Act' seeks to close loophole in criminal justice system

    Wednesday, January 24 2018 3:57 AM EST2018-01-24 08:57:37 GMT
    (Image: Hawaii News Now/file)(Image: Hawaii News Now/file)

    The Senate Judiciary Committee is set to consider the "Peter Boy Kema Act," a bill that would protect victims of crime — like Peter Boy Kema — by ensuring those responsible do not escape justice. SB 2322 looks to eliminate the ten year statute of limitations on manslaughter cases. The bill refers to the ten year statute of limitations as "a potential loophole in Hawaii's criminal justice system."  In 2016, Jaylin Kema ple...

    More >>

    The Senate Judiciary Committee is set to consider the "Peter Boy Kema Act," a bill that would protect victims of crime — like Peter Boy Kema — by ensuring those responsible do not escape justice. SB 2322 looks to eliminate the ten year statute of limitations on manslaughter cases. The bill refers to the ten year statute of limitations as "a potential loophole in Hawaii's criminal justice system."  In 2016, Jaylin Kema ple...

    More >>
  • Hawaii's Keala Settle could grace Oscar stage after 'This is Me' earns nomination

    Hawaii's Keala Settle could grace Oscar stage after 'This is Me' earns nomination

    Wednesday, January 24 2018 3:52 AM EST2018-01-24 08:52:58 GMT
    (Image: The Greatest Showman)(Image: The Greatest Showman)

    Fresh off a Golden Globe win for the hit song This is Me, the cast of The Greatest Showman — including Hawaii's own Keala Settle — could win gold on another Hollywood stage. The song, written by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul, earned a nomination for best Original Song. The cast found out earlier this week after the song sat at the top of the Billboard chart for three consecutive weeks. Settle plays the bearded lady in the film, which has received outstan...

    More >>

    Fresh off a Golden Globe win for the hit song This is Me, the cast of The Greatest Showman — including Hawaii's own Keala Settle — could win gold on another Hollywood stage. The song, written by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul, earned a nomination for best Original Song. The cast found out earlier this week after the song sat at the top of the Billboard chart for three consecutive weeks. Settle plays the bearded lady in the film, which has received outstan...

    More >>
Powered by Frankly