Request for rail rebid turns into rant - Hawaii News Now - KGMB and KHNL

Request for rail rebid turns into rant

Councilman Tom Berg Councilman Tom Berg
Joseph Stewart Joseph Stewart
Andrew Robbins Andrew Robbins

By Tim Sakahara - bio | email

HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - A councilmember asks for Kleenex he gets so upset about the rail and it's all because of a $234 million difference in price.

Councilman Tom Berg wants the city to rebid for the rail car contract but city attorney's aren't about to budge.

"It's just frustration. I'm looking at $234 million being flushed down the toilet and we're getting a contractor who doesn't really know how to build rail cars. I'm upset with this!" said Tom Berg, talking about Ansaldo Honolulu, the company city awarded the core systems contract to.

The Budget Committee meeting turned into a rant on rail.  Bombardier's bid to build and operate transit cars was disqualified essentially over a disagreement over liability insurance.

"The city basically asked for a contract for apples and bombardier proposed oranges," said Joseph Stewart, Kobayashi, Sugita & Goda, which represents the City of Honolulu.

Stewart says Bombardier received six different documents about the city's concerns so they should have known.

"Looking at the documents in writing it's clear that Bombardier should have and did understand that because of the fact that..."

"Did we help them to understand that?" asked Ikaika Anderson, Honolulu City Councilmember during testimony.

"Certainly by issuing responses to the questions from bidders stating that the city is not willing to make this change," responded Stewart.

"What we're hearing here is an incredible cover story. Maybe the attorney is doing his job but it's weaving fact and fiction together to try and make it sound good," said Andrew Robbins, Bombardier Vice President. "The city and HART (Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation) staff either did not understand the Hawaii procurement code, which I believe is true, or they felt they could make any decision they wanted."

Robbins argues they had discussions with the city about doors and windows on the trains but the city never mentioned the issue that would disqualify them despite being the lowest bidder.

"They played gotcha, gotcha you're out.  It's wrong. The whole point of that (Hawaii Administrative Rule) is the city is supposed to be an agent for the taxpayer, get the best deal, you don't just throw the best value out because of one sentence you say wait a minute the sentence is no good, we don't like it. We want you, you have a great deal but you need to get rid of that sentence," said Robbins.

He says the city's attorneys don't know the liability law and their contract language is flawed. And they were bringing up the mistakes to prevent a lawsuit down the line.

"We didn't want to make these anti rail critics right that you're going to get all these claims on this project and the costs are going to escalate. We wanted clarity now. We want to get the contract right now," said Robbins.

"If I had a box of Kleenex I would have left the room. I'm in tears. I'm really in tears sir. I can't believe the way the city has treated you. The lawyers are feeding off the trough, the taxpayers trough and I'm livid right now, I'm trying to hold back!" said Berg.

After all that the committee deferred the issue but Bombardier still has options. It can appeal in court.  It also has a pending request with the Federal Transit Administration.

Copyright 2011 Hawaii News Now. All rights reserved.

  • Hawaii News Now headlinesNewsMore>>

  • World Cup win gives France new set of heroes, needed boost

    World Cup win gives France new set of heroes, needed boost

    Monday, July 16 2018 3:45 AM EDT2018-07-16 07:45:47 GMT
    Tuesday, July 17 2018 12:15 AM EDT2018-07-17 04:15:21 GMT
    (AP Photo/Thibault Camus). The name of French soccer player Kylian Mbappe is projected onto the Arc de Triomphe as soccer fans invade the Champs Elysees avenue after France won the soccer World Cup final match between France and Croatia, Sunday, July 1...(AP Photo/Thibault Camus). The name of French soccer player Kylian Mbappe is projected onto the Arc de Triomphe as soccer fans invade the Champs Elysees avenue after France won the soccer World Cup final match between France and Croatia, Sunday, July 1...
    World Cup, World Cup and more World Cup _ that's all France is talking about.More >>
    World Cup, World Cup and more World Cup _ that's all France is talking about.More >>
  • Judge temporarily halts deportation of reunified families

    Judge temporarily halts deportation of reunified families

    Monday, July 16 2018 12:03 PM EDT2018-07-16 16:03:29 GMT
    Tuesday, July 17 2018 12:14 AM EDT2018-07-17 04:14:14 GMT
    The American Civil Liberties Union is asking a federal judge to order the federal government to hold off one week on deporting reunified families that were separated at the border. (Source: Raycom Media, file)The American Civil Liberties Union is asking a federal judge to order the federal government to hold off one week on deporting reunified families that were separated at the border. (Source: Raycom Media, file)

    The American Civil Liberties Union is asking a federal judge to order the federal government to hold off one week on deporting reunified families that were separated at the border.

    More >>

    The American Civil Liberties Union is asking a federal judge to order the federal government to hold off one week on deporting reunified families that were separated at the border.

    More >>
  • HPD now searching for missing evidence relating to federal public corruption investigation

    HPD now searching for missing evidence relating to federal public corruption investigation

    Tuesday, July 17 2018 12:01 AM EDT2018-07-17 04:01:04 GMT

    Honolulu police are searching for missing evidence relating to the FBI's massive corruption case against the Kealohas.

    More >>

    Honolulu police are searching for missing evidence relating to the FBI's massive corruption case against the Kealohas.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly